Cartoonists Brad Guigar and Dave Kellett dig into the many ways we react to humor — from full-on belly laughs to the silent internal “that was good” response. After that the way, they tackle some big (and surprisingly relatable) topics:

• Are they actually going to use Patreon Quips?
• Dave’s Bad 2025 — what went wrong, what he learned, and why it matters
• Why you never stop building an audience, even when things feel “established”
• And yes… being scared of Reddit comments is universal!

Summary

In this episode of Comic Lab, hosts Dave Kellett and Brad Guigar dive into the nature of humor in comics, prompted by a listener’s question about whether funny comics truly elicit laughter or if they are simply enjoyable. Brad and Dave explore the subjective nature of humor, sharing their own experiences with laughter and recognition of craft in comedy. Next, they delve into the ongoing journey of building and maintaining an audience in the ever-evolving landscape of comics. They emphasize that there is no such thing as a ‘built audience.’ Audience engagement is a continuous process that requires constant effort and adaptation. Drawing on the metaphor of the Ship of Theseus, they discuss how creators must regularly replace and update their strategies to keep their audience engaged, acknowledging that audience members may leave for various reasons, including life changes or simply forgetting about the content.

The conversation also touches on the emotional toll of negative feedback, particularly on platforms like Reddit, where creators often face harsh criticism. Brad and Dave share personal anecdotes about dealing with trolls and the importance of focusing on the positive aspects of audience engagement. They conclude by reinforcing the idea that the creative journey is ongoing, and that every creator must continually learn and adapt to thrive in the industry.

Takeaways

• “Not every year is going to be gangbusters.”
• There’s no such thing as a built audience; you’re always in building mode.
• Audience engagement is like the Ship of Theseus; it’s constantly changing.
• You should aim to gain 2-6% new audience every month to replace those who leave.
• Negative comments often come from unhappy individuals; don’t take them personally.
• Every creator must continually learn and adapt to thrive in the industry.