• Home
  • Contact
  • FAQs
    • What is Webcomics.com?
    • Member Benefits
    • How To Post an Article or News Item
    • How to Post a Webcomic on the List
    • How to Post a Comic
    • Terms of Service
  • Forums
  • WebComics List
  • Benefits
    • Print Vendors: Get multiple quotes
    • Banner stand: Discount
    • Consultation discount
    • “How To Make Webcomics” book: discount
    • “Webcomics Handbook”: discount
    • ALL benefits
  • My Account
    • Welcome
    • What is Webcomics.com?
    • My Subscription
    • Join us!
  • Account
  • Membership List
Twitter Email RSS

Webcomics.com

How To Make WebComics

Webcomics Handbook

‹ Hot Seat Critique: Call for Entries Friday Archive Dive: Digital Downloads at Cons ›

Writing: Tell it Like it Is — or Tell it Like it Ought To Be?

As a writer, it’s inevitable that you’ll come down to a fundamental crossroads in your creative philosophy: Tell it like it is… or tell it like it ought to be? Even if you’re doing writing that has a tenuous relationship to reality — fantasy, comedy, etc. — your characters and their actions will bear out your decision on this basic question.

Writing Creativity icon

The pragmatist

On one hand, it’s the pragmatist who says that they’re going to reflect the real world and all its warts. Your job isn’t to change the world. Rather, your goal is to hold a mirror up to the universe and tell stories based in the reality that we all share. After all, the pragmatist reasons, the stories that resonate with readers are the ones that are True — and that truth in the story is what makes a good story into an extraordinary one. After all, if you lose touch with that, your characters aren’t going to seem as real. Maybe this leads to stereotyping — all nurses are female, all Asians are good at math, all African-Americans excell at basketball — but a pragmatist insists that you’re able to say volumes about your character by either adhering to that stereotype or writing the character who is defined as breaking the stereotype.

The idealist

On the other hand, it’s the idealist who says that writing has the power to shape the world. And this goes beyond showing us a world that we can all strive for. If people are continually presented certain situations in the stories that a society shares, it will inevitably lead to an assumption that the world is supposed to be that way. For example, this mindset stresses the importance of depicting girls who take an interest in — and excell at — science. If we only write girls who play with dolls and stare into mirrors, we’re telling society that this is how girls are supposed to act. It becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy, the idealist says. And we take part in enabling a generation of young girls to sell themselves short.

And in the interest of accuracy, I should probably note an important third aspect of writing — Tell it like it was. This would encompass things like journal comics, historical accounts, news/current events features, etc. You might argue that this is actually the pragmatist philosophy applied to non-fiction, but in the interest of simplicity, let’s keep the discussion between IS and OUGHT.

I don’t think either side is right, and neither is wrong. I can think of excellent examples of quality writing that could fall into either camp. And, I’ll bet there are examples of writers who keep a foot on both sides.

The question is… Which is it for you?

by Brad Guigar on June 12, 2014
Posted In: Writing
Comments available to logged in users only.



Recent comments

  • hpkomic on Managing commissions
  • Brad Guigar on Tweet and sour
  • Kulanah on Tweet and sour
  • Kulanah on Tweet and sour
  • Andrew Fraser on Tweet and sour

Search



Webcomics.com Poll

I design my comic specifically for smartphones and digital tablets.

  • Disagree (52%, 178 Votes)
  • Agree (48%, 165 Votes)

Total Voters: 343

Loading ... Loading ...
  • Polls Archive

Categories

  • Archive Dive
  • Articles
    • Advertising
    • Art
    • Business
    • Community
    • Conventions
    • Creativity
    • Crowdfunding
    • Digital publishing
    • Image prep
    • Lettering
    • Marketing / Social Media
    • Merchandise
    • Print publishing
    • Tech
    • Web site
      • Web Site Design
    • Writing
  • ComicLab
  • Edited and Ready
  • Events
  • Guest
  • Hot Seat critiques
  • Information
  • Interviews
  • Livestream Chat
  • Mail Bag
  • Member Benefits
  • Promos
  • Site News
  • Studios
  • Surviving Creativity
  • To-Do List
  • Uncategorized
  • Video
  • Webcomics Confidential
  • Webcomics Weekly
  • Webcomics.com Poll

Tags

ad revenue AdSense advertising Comic Easel comments composition contract copyright creativity exercise credit cards Crowdfunding digital lettering digital publishing Facebook holiday Humor IP KDP Kickstarter Kindle legal lettering line weight Longform comics Manga Studio merchandise NCS panels Patreon Promotion PulsePoint readers revenue SEO shipping social media Square taxes trademark Twitter typography Web design word balloons WordPress writing

Special Features

Just now, in the forum…

  • Mixing First and Third Person Captions
  • Help with Toocheke
  • Label Printer for shipping
  • Patreon Merch
  • Pricing Your Comics

Recent Posts

  • ComicLab Ep 268 — Special Guest Ellen Woodbury of “Pizza Cake Comics”
  • “Poor Man’s Copyright”
  • Blambot sale
  • February To-Do List
  • ComicLab Ep 267 — How to turn OFF creativity

Recent Replies

  • Brad Guigar on Mixing First and Third Person Captions
  • Brad Guigar on Help with Toocheke
  • Brad Guigar on Label Printer for shipping
  • Andrew Fraser on Label Printer for shipping
  • Brad Guigar on Label Printer for shipping

Recent Topics

  • Mixing First and Third Person Captions by jpactor
  • Help with Toocheke by Andrew Fraser
  • Label Printer for shipping by Andrew Fraser
  • Patreon Merch by Jaycee Knight
  • Pricing Your Comics by Jaycee Knight

Recent Comments

  • hpkomic on Managing commissions
  • Brad Guigar on Tweet and sour
  • Kulanah on Tweet and sour
  • Kulanah on Tweet and sour
  • Andrew Fraser on Tweet and sour
  • My Subscription
  • Store
  • Terms of Service
  • Account
  • Membership List

©2007-2023 Webcomics.com | Powered by WordPress with ComicPress | Subscribe: RSS | Back to Top ↑