• Home
  • Contact
  • FAQs
    • What is Webcomics.com?
    • Member Benefits
    • How To Post an Article or News Item
    • How to Post a Webcomic on the List
    • How to Post a Comic
    • Terms of Service
  • Forums
  • WebComics List
  • Benefits
    • Print Vendors: Get multiple quotes
    • Banner stand: Discount
    • Consultation discount
    • “How To Make Webcomics” book: discount
    • “Webcomics Handbook”: discount
    • ALL benefits
  • My Account
    • Welcome
    • What is Webcomics.com?
    • My Subscription
    • Join us!
  • Account
  • Membership List
Twitter Email RSS

Webcomics.com

How To Make WebComics

Webcomics Handbook

‹ Friday Archive Dive: Using GMail to handle a cu... Mailbag: Selling your buffer ›

IDGI and Humor: Risk and Reward

So the comic was pretty straightforward. The punchline was solid. But the cartoonist felt the need to explain his joke with a little character who made the punchline painfully obvious. And, in so doing, completely ruined any humor that had been created.

On a Web site, Comics I Don’t Understand, the comment ran thusly:

Metatexts, hidden panels, side comments… who started this horrible trend, and how can we make it stop?

I stared at my screen, quite literally gobsmacked.

“Who started this horrible trend“?!

This man who has been updating a site — for more than a decade — with the central purpose of highlighting comics that didn’t hammer you over the head with a punchline… is that the man who just wrote that sentence?!

And before you report me to Blogs I Don’t Understand dot com, please know that I write that with tongue planted firmly in cheek.

However, this highlights a fundamental rule of humor: Nobody wants to get the IDGI [“I Don’t Get It“]. And if you deliver a punchline and your reader/audience responds with an IDGI… well, that’s a missed opportunity — one you can learn from.  BUT… if you write every gag under the constant fear of an IDGI… you’ll never write the level of humor you’re capable of.

And I’ll tell you why.

The content you are trying to access is only available to members.

by Brad Guigar on December 15, 2014
Posted In: Writing
Comments available to logged in users only.


Recent comments

  • dogss on You need to publish a vertical scroll NOW
  • Brad Guigar on Exclusive Member Benefit: Webcomics Handbook
  • BuddyGoodboyEsq on Exclusive Member Benefit: Webcomics Handbook
  • Ian on Getting Started with the Right Attitude
  • Brad Guigar on Getting Started with the Right Attitude

Search




Webcomics.com Poll

I design my comic specifically for smartphones and digital tablets.

  • Disagree (52%, 175 Votes)
  • Agree (48%, 161 Votes)

Total Voters: 336

Loading ... Loading ...
  • Polls Archive

Categories

  • Archive Dive
  • Articles
    • Advertising
    • Art
    • Business
    • Community
    • Conventions
    • Creativity
    • Crowdfunding
    • Digital publishing
    • Image prep
    • Lettering
    • Marketing / Social Media
    • Merchandise
    • Print publishing
    • Tech
    • Web site
      • Web Site Design
    • Writing
  • ComicLab
  • Edited and Ready
  • Events
  • Guest
  • Hot Seat critiques
  • Information
  • Interviews
  • Livestream Chat
  • Mail Bag
  • Member Benefits
  • Promos
  • Site News
  • Studios
  • Surviving Creativity
  • To-Do List
  • Uncategorized
  • Video
  • Webcomics Confidential
  • Webcomics Weekly
  • Webcomics.com Poll

Tags

AdSense advertising Comic Easel comments composition contract copyright creativity exercise credit cards Crowdfunding digital lettering digital publishing Facebook Google Analytics holiday Humor IP KDP Kickstarter Kindle legal lettering line weight Longform comics Manga Studio merchandise NCS panels Patreon Promotion PulsePoint readers revenue SEO shipping social media Square taxes trademark Twitter typography Web design word balloons WordPress writing

Special Features

Just now, in the forum…

  • Mixing First and Third Person Captions
  • Help with Toocheke
  • Label Printer for shipping
  • Patreon Merch
  • Pricing Your Comics

Recent Posts

  • ComicLab Ep 242 — San Diego Comic Con review
  • Start planning holiday merchandise — NOW
  • How many panels per page?
  • Telegraphing a joke
  • Manga-inspired word balloons — and why you might want to rethink them

Recent Replies

  • Brad Guigar on Mixing First and Third Person Captions
  • Brad Guigar on Help with Toocheke
  • Brad Guigar on Label Printer for shipping
  • Andrew Fraser on Label Printer for shipping
  • Brad Guigar on Label Printer for shipping

Recent Topics

  • Mixing First and Third Person Captions by jpactor
  • Help with Toocheke by Andrew Fraser
  • Label Printer for shipping by Andrew Fraser
  • Patreon Merch by Jaycee Knight
  • Pricing Your Comics by Jaycee Knight

Recent Comments

  • dogss on You need to publish a vertical scroll NOW
  • Brad Guigar on Exclusive Member Benefit: Webcomics Handbook
  • BuddyGoodboyEsq on Exclusive Member Benefit: Webcomics Handbook
  • Ian on Getting Started with the Right Attitude
  • Brad Guigar on Getting Started with the Right Attitude
  • My Subscription
  • Store
  • Terms of Service
  • Account
  • Membership List

©2007-2022 Webcomics.com | Powered by WordPress with ComicPress | Subscribe: RSS | Back to Top ↑