Charlie Boatner
Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Charlie BoatnerParticipant
That is a good question, and a difficult one. Although snacks do seem Rose’s go-to when things get tough, they don’t define her. Some of the strips aren’t about food (or her). But how do you elevator pitch a good-natured human? Mary Tyler Moore? Archie?
So the “food” line works unless you come up with something else. She IS a girl trying to understand adulthood, but that’s hard to say in a catchy way.
My thought at the moment, f.w.i.w., “Rose loves life and dessert. But dessert’s easier.”
Charlie BoatnerParticipantPam, I’m glad you re-upped for Webcomics.com. Your frequent comments and tone are important in this community!
Charlie BoatnerParticipantThink about the backgrounds more. You have appealing-looking characters; you obviously enjoy drawing them. But you seem to rely on coloring to fill the rest of the panel.
Show more about the kind of building that O’Reilly works in (is it a lab or a bar). Show more trees or bushes or rocks around the beach. Draw some cool underwater foliage and coral.
You put some nice detail in the establishing shot in the first panel. Page 2, panel 5 has nice depth and detail. I suggest more of that.
Charlie BoatnerParticipantMira seems to be reacting to the sense of color saturation I get when first opening your strip. But if she’s suggesting removing the banner ad, can you afford that?
(Maybe the illustration in the logo distracts from the illustration in the strip.)
I think your web design is great. Everything fits on the screen, so I can click from strip to strip without scrolling.
Your character design is appealing. However, dialogue contains terminology that is unfamiliar to me, and I don’t know the game screen and manual conventions. My loss. Do you have a plan for getting your work to an informed audience?
Re: the thread not going anywhere – when I visit webcomics.com, I look for recent updates (as I did this time). I get the sense that none of us are checking the site frequently, which means few updates, allowing threads to look unpopular and age quickly.
Charlie BoatnerParticipantHi Jenn! Your pages are very clear and appealing!
If you’re choosing between “Blightrun” or “Aldwen Archives,” you might as well choose for the long-term. Neither is self-explanatory like “Evil Inc” or “Biff the Vampire.”
Have you considered an evocative, intriguing title, even if it doesn’t explain? ‘Hamlet’s Danish’ or ‘Girls with Slingshots’ makes me curious, even if I don’t know what I’m getting into.
But many webstrips have chosen to teach their audience to expect good things from the site, whatever the name. PVP? XKCD? You can too.
Charlie BoatnerParticipantYour latest (#16132) looks good. Outlines for the balloons for clarity, but merging with the borders gives openness.
Charlie BoatnerParticipantGreat, I can read the strip! I love Kevin’s frustrations with his boss and executives!
Charlie BoatnerParticipantYou need to work on your flow. I’m confused by the jumping around.
Strip one suggests you’re going to tell your life, starting with your parents, in full color. Strip two, you change to an oral narrative format, three color. Strip three changes to a documentary format, and goes back in time another generation and changes the main character to your grandmother. Strip five — who is Takuma?
I recommend choosing a year to start, then going forward. If you must change point-of-view or tell a story within a story, telegraph it clearly.
I’m interested in the story you’re telling. I’m interested in your grandmother’s story. I’m very interested in your mom’s story. Your sincerity is evident. Keep up the good work!
Charlie BoatnerParticipantYou’re getting a lot of great feedback, here! I’ll probably just end up repeating it.
You described the strip as five geeky friends and I would have liked to see more of the other four, interacting. Kevin reacting to the funny setups is good, but I’m a sucker for characterization. Fondness for characters builds reader loyalty.
I see what Brandon was saying about the punchlines. For instance, the doughnut strip is very funny, but needs to be sharpened. Deleting Kevin’s last balloon and the doctor’s last (second) balloon might do it.
On the other hand, the “art is hard” strip — a very clever concept — needs something added. Maybe a third absurdist element walking into the last panel, just as Kevin complains.
The “storm/grocery” strip is quite timely, as I type with storm warnings on the radio in the background. That was one of the first pages I found http://kevstees.com/?p=1611 . That’s a readable size and resolution. If I could have found forward and back buttons, I would have been happy.
Charlie BoatnerParticipantScrapping and rebuilding takes a lot of commitment, Cameron. I’m impressed!
Charlie BoatnerParticipantGreat character design and a beautiful thick-and-thin line. I am not a gamer, but all of the strips are fun to look at, although obviously I only get a few (Wolfenstein being my favorite, so far, and Halo the most obscure).
Of the five navigation buttons, only RANDOM is working for me. It gives your site the appearance of having only one post.
I am suffering the exactly the same Color vs B&W dilemma that you are. I don’t have the time for color and feel more confident in my B&W creative choices. But, hey, B&W didn’t hurt PVP in its initial years. I’ll be interested if this debate continues.
Charlie BoatnerParticipantI always enjoy your style, and your character design is appealing, but Watterson was using that panel layout to distinguish different scenes; while your strip is eleven panels in sequence.
Charlie BoatnerParticipantIt’s hard to comment without seeing the strips in question. I get your problem — you want to base a character on a real person who was black, male, sketchy, and employed as a super.
But if he is your ONLY black character, some readers may feel that’s a statement. Fred Sanford (if you know the reference) without Lamont and the others to provide perspective might be offensive.
I would not call editing your own work censorship. There’s nothing wrong with waiting until you have a good story to tell with more than one representative of a group.
But I’m writing as a male WASP.
Charlie BoatnerParticipantI didn’t see a link, so I googled for it. Is this it? http://h4ab.smackjeeves.com/comics/429552/hope-for-a-breeze/
The site design is average. A little busy, with the pink cloud border, two ads, and other colorful things. But it allows me to read your strip and doesn’t distract too much, which is the important thing. (Does Smackjeeves allow any flexibility anyway?)
Your strip is very readable, and the artwork at the beginning is compelling and attractive. The Dedication is powerful. However the changes in art style distract me, like the jump from h4ab-0-26/ to h4ab-1-03/. Are you using different artists?
Charlie BoatnerParticipantYour comments made my day, Pam, thank you! I have wondered whether the Snoof’s lack of a backstory would be befuddling. I have a possible one in mind, but it’s complicated, and revealing the mystery is a potential storyline, not something I want to dump on the reader at the beginning. Putting it in an ABOUT would be a spoiler. I keep mulling…
The FIRST button has been fixed, it’s good Brad pointed that out. It turned out to be a bug in the host site. Clay, the designer of the Squarespace webcomics template, generously helped me out.
-
AuthorPosts